BlockNews.com
  • Crypto
  • NFT
  • Metaverse
  • DeFi
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Opinion
  • Guides
No Result
View All Result
SUBSCRIBE
BlockNews.com
  • Crypto
  • NFT
  • Metaverse
  • DeFi
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Opinion
  • Guides
No Result
View All Result
BlockNews.com
No Result
View All Result
Home Crypto

Utility Token versus Security Token Debate Hits the Courts

BlockNews Team by BlockNews Team
September 4, 2022
in Crypto, Finance, Politics
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
Utility-Security
1
SHARES
11
VIEWS
Share on TwitterShare on Reddit

The debate over whether a new digital asset is a utility token or a security token makes a significant difference regarding registration with the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) and subsequent reporting and disclosure obligations. While a utility token is issued for a limited, consumptive purpose, security tokens are more akin to traditional stock in public companies. Because of this, the SEC is empowered to regulate the latter. How to make this decision is a million-dollar question. A recent jury verdict and subsequent federal court ruling try to parse out where this line is—or should—be drawn.

You might also like

Coinbase Argues Software Services Are Not Securities: A Case Against the SEC

Nigeria Now Enabled to Make Direct Crypto Purchases Through MetaMask

FTX Is Looking To Recover $460M From A Venture Capital Supported By Bankman-Fried’s Alameda Research

Utility vs. Security Token

Utility tokens are designed and intended for a specific purpose—such as an in-game token. They provide access to a closed ecosystem of users to access goods and services and operate on other blockchains. Think of a utility token like an arcade token or a casino chip. An example of a significant project that uses utility tokens is Filecoin—the market leader in providing cloud storage space—with its utility token FIL—which is used to access the network and the storage space.

Security tokens are an entirely different creature. These tokens offer ownership interests in another asset in a digitalized manner. In other words, a security token is like a piece of a public company´s stock stored on the blockchain. An example of a security token is INX—which offers purchasers dividends and interest payments. INX represents the first registered security on the blockchain.

Utility tokens are issued to the public through initial coin offerings (“ICOs”) in an unregistered fashion. On the other hand, security tokens typically mandate a security token offering (“STO”)—basically like IPOs for digital assets—registered, regulated, and offered with the SEC seal of approval.

In the Courts: Audet vs. Fraser

From 2016 to today, this case conjures memories of the utility versus security token distinction. In this class action lawsuit—Audet v. Fraser—a class sued defendant Stuart Fraser and two crypto mining companies in connection with offering several crypto assets allegedly securities and not registered as such. In addition to the “Paycoin,” the defendant also provided the Hashlet, Hashcoin, and Hashpoints to the public. The defendant was alleged to have defrauded and made multiple misrepresentations to the public about these products.

The Jury´s Decision, the Court´s Ruling, and Next Steps

In November 2021, a federal jury decided whether these products were “securities.” In a stunning jury verdict, the jury decided—after applying the Howey Test—that these digital assets were not securities under governing law. This was an essential verdict because it marks the first time a federal jury has considered whether a digital asset is a security.

On June 3, 2022, a federal court ordered a new trial. The judge rejected the jury´s verdict that Paycoin was not a security and reasoned that a reasonable investor would have expected that this product had the characteristics of a security and therefore was security. The new trial will focus on this one product.

Significance

The Wall Street Journal frames the issue perfectly: “whether digital tokens are, for legal purposes, more similar to stocks or gold.” Similar to stocks, they should be treated and regulated like traditional securities. If they are similar to gold, they are commodities and not securities; therefore, they do not have to be handled as securities because they are not securities. However, the line between the two is hard to draw. Until Congress provides more clarity on this issue, all interested parties, as well as the U.S. courts, will have to grapple with these finer points and straddle this blurred line.

Conclusion

In brief, a utility token is offered for a limited, specific purpose, while a security token gives the holder a (digitalized) stake in the company. Deciding such a distinction is challenging. The jury in Audet v. Fraser ruled that the digital assets in the case were not securities. However, a federal court soon ordered a new trial on one of these digital assets. This demonstrates nothing more than a lack of clarity on whether a novel digital asset should be characterized as a utility token or a security token. What is agreed upon is that the courts will be the avenue individuals will turn towards to help them make this determination.

Tags: BlockchaincryptoWeb3
TweetShareShare

Recommended For You

Coinbase Argues Software Services Are Not Securities: A Case Against the SEC

by BlockNews Team
March 24, 2023
0
coinbase

Coinbase CLO Paul Grewal announced that the company provided details to the SEC about why staking services are not securities Grewal saw the SEC’s perspective on software services...

Read more

Nigeria Now Enabled to Make Direct Crypto Purchases Through MetaMask

by BlockNews Team
March 24, 2023
0
metamask

Nigerians can now buy crypto using MetaMask instead of centralized exchanges Crypto fintech MoonPay merged with ConsenSys to allow users to buy cryptocurrencies through direct bank transfers Nigeria...

Read more

FTX Is Looking To Recover $460M From A Venture Capital Supported By Bankman-Fried’s Alameda Research

by BlockNews Team
March 24, 2023
0
ftx

FTX files for return of $460 million investment funds made to venture capital firm by Sam Bankman-Fried through Alameda Research. When he invested, Sam Bankman-Fried was allegedly in...

Read more

OpenZeppelin Reveals Top 10 Blockchain Hacking Techniques in 2022

by BlockNews Team
March 23, 2023
0
OpenZeppelin

OpenZeppelin's top 10 hacking methods of 2022 serve as a sobering reminder of the value of cybersecurity and the need for ongoing research to make blockchain systems more...

Read more

Links DAO To Buy Scottish Golf Course For $1M

by BlockNews Team
March 23, 2023
0
Links DAO

Links DAO has won the bid to  buy a Scottish golf course for close to $1 million. This follows a landslide community vote in favor of the purchase...

Read more
Next Post
Shibu-Land

Shiba Inu Enters the Metaverse with Virtual Land

Related News

justice department

Justice Department Announces Major International Crypto Enforcement Action

January 28, 2023
Crypto.com-logo

Crypto.com Introduces Google Pay and Apple Pay Services for Canadian Users

October 7, 2022
Hydro-Quebec

The Canadian Utility CEO That Proposed Banning New Power To Crypto Exits

January 26, 2023

Browse by Category

  • Breaking News
  • Business
  • Crypto
  • DeFi
  • Finance
  • Gaming
  • Guides
  • Investing
  • Media
  • Metaverse
  • NFT
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Social
  • Technology
  • Uncategorized
BlockNews.com

BlockNews.com brings you the most important Crypto and NFT news in the space.

CATEGORIES

  • Breaking News
  • Business
  • Crypto
  • DeFi
  • Finance
  • Gaming
  • Guides
  • Investing
  • Media
  • Metaverse
  • NFT
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Social
  • Technology
  • Uncategorized

RECENT POSTS

  • Coinbase Argues Software Services Are Not Securities: A Case Against the SEC March 24, 2023
  • Nigeria Now Enabled to Make Direct Crypto Purchases Through MetaMask March 24, 2023
  • FTX Is Looking To Recover $460M From A Venture Capital Supported By Bankman-Fried’s Alameda Research March 24, 2023

© 2022 BlockNews.com - Crypto and NFT news website by JRNY Club.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Crypto
  • NFT
  • Metaverse
  • DeFi
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Opinion
  • Guides

© 2022 BlockNews.com - Crypto and NFT news website by JRNY Club.

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?