BlockNews
FOLLOW ON X
  • BITCOIN
  • CRYPTO
    • ETHEREUM
    • RIPPLE XRP
    • SOLANA
    • CARDANO
    • BINANCE BNB
    • DOGECOIN
    • TRON
    • SUI
    • CHAINLINK
    • LITECOIN
  • FINANCE
  • POLITICS
  • MEMECOINS
  • NFT
  • OPINION
No Result
View All Result
BlockNews
  • BITCOIN
  • CRYPTO
    • ETHEREUM
    • RIPPLE XRP
    • SOLANA
    • CARDANO
    • BINANCE BNB
    • DOGECOIN
    • TRON
    • SUI
    • CHAINLINK
    • LITECOIN
  • FINANCE
  • POLITICS
  • MEMECOINS
  • NFT
  • OPINION
No Result
View All Result
BlockNews
Home BUSINESS

Grayscale Accuses SEC Of Being Too Harsh On Spot Bitcoin Funds

BlockNews Team by BlockNews Team
October 14, 2022
in BUSINESS, CRYPTO, MEDIA
Reading Time: 4 mins read
3
SHARES
49
VIEWS
Share on XShare in TelegramShare on Reddit

Grayscale Investment LLC has accused the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) of being excessively harsh on bitcoin trading. 

This case traces back to June 29, 2022, when the New York Stock Exchange proposed the conversion of Grayscale’s $15 billion bitcoin investment trust into an exchange-traded fund (ETF). The proposal, however, did not go through, as the SEC rejected it. The case was controversial since the regulator had previously approved ETFs based on bitcoin futures. 

Grayscale is the most prominent digital asset management firm worldwide, recording $26.4 billion in assets under management by March 2022. Worth noting also the federal appellate courts are the ones that handle challenges to the final SEC orders, not trial courts.

Grayscale takes the SEC to the federal appellate courts

According to the report, digital asset manager Grayscale filed its opening brief against the SEC on Tuesday, October 11, challenging the Commission’s decision to deny Grayscale’s proposal to convert the Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) to a spot Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF). The case was filed in the United States Courts of Appeals in the District of Columbia Circuit. The brief claims: “The SEC’s knockback is “arbitrary, capricious and discriminatory.”

 From Grayscale’s argument, the regulator treats spot Bitcoin (BTC) exchange-traded products (ETPs) with extraordinary harshness and is doing this “over its legal mandate.” 

The asset manager told the D.C. Circuit that its bitcoin trust is just as susceptible to fraud and manipulation as the exchange-traded bitcoin futures funds, noting that the SEC had approved the latter in the past. Citing Grayscale chief legal officer Craig Salm:

“Bitcoin spot prices and bitcoin futures are subject to the same fraud risk that has historically worried the SEC. So, logically speaking, if you are okay with one, you must also be okay with the other because you otherwise would be arbitrary.”

It is imperative to note that Grayscale’s bitcoin trust is based on an index of spot, or instantaneous, bitcoin trading prices. It is also worth noting that the bitcoin funds ETF approved by the SEC rely on nearly identical bitcoin trading price indexes. 

According to Grayscale, the SEC blocked a proposal to enhance security and simplicity for investors to access crypto. According to the asset manager, this was the ‘only reasonable conclusion’ from the regulator’s move to deny the proposal.  

Reference to special harshness

According to Grayscale’s legal representatives at Munger, Tolles & Olson, bitcoin futures and spot bitcoin prices are founded atop the same foundational spot markets for BTC. According to the legal reps, the SEC’s refusal to approve an ETF that references actual bitcoin, instead of bitcoin futures contracts, indicates ‘extraordinary harshness based on the regulator’s opinion about bitcoin’s merit vis-à-vis other investment forms. In their words:

“Although Bitcoin may be a relatively new asset, the legal issue here is straightforward. The Commission has violated the APA’s most basic requirements by failing to justify its vastly different treatment of Bitcoin Futures ETPs and spot Bitcoin ETPs.”

Grayscale also complained that the Commission’s “significant-market test” to determine whether an exchange’s application to list an ETP is “tailored to prevent fraud and manipulative actions” is flawed, highlighting that the SEC has set the bar so high for industry players to reach. 

While the SEC did not make a direct response to Grayscale’s filing, the Commission explained:

“Our decision to reject Grayscale’s proposal for a spot bitcoin ETF should not be seen as a judgment on the considerable perks of bitcoin and bitcoin futures contracts. Neither should it be viewed as an assessment of whether bitcoin or the whole blockchain technology has utility or value as an innovation or an investment.”

According to Grayscale, the Commission should submit its brief by November 9, 2022, after which the asset manager will submit a reply brief on November 30. The two parties will then offer a final brief by December 21. 

Disclaimer: BlockNews provides independent reporting on crypto, blockchain, and digital finance. All content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Readers should do their own research before making investment decisions. Some articles may use AI tools to assist in drafting, but every piece is reviewed and edited by our editorial team of experienced crypto writers and analysts before publication.
Tags: Bitcoingreyscalesec
Tweet1ShareShare
BlockNews Team

BlockNews Team

DON'T MISS THESE! HOT OFF THE PRESS

Shiba Inu Makes History With Folks Finance Integration, Price Sees Fresh Momentum
CRYPTO

Shiba Inu Makes History With Folks Finance Integration, Price Sees Fresh Momentum

September 4, 2025
PEPE Faces 15% Downside Risk as Trading Volumes Collapse
CRYPTO

PEPE Faces 15% Downside Risk as Trading Volumes Collapse

September 4, 2025
Dogecoin Price Analysis: Lower Highs Form as Volume Expands on Declines
CRYPTO

Dogecoin Price Analysis: Lower Highs Form as Volume Expands on Declines

September 4, 2025
XRP $50,000 Price Predictions and the Disappearing Forbes Report Stir Market Frenzy
CRYPTO

XRP $50,000 Price Predictions and the Disappearing Forbes Report Stir Market Frenzy

September 4, 2025
Market Summary: What Happened in Crypto Today?
CRYPTO

Market Summary: What Happened in Crypto Today?

September 3, 2025
Fat-Finger Error Dumps Pump Fun Streamer Coin 99%, Then Surges 10,000%? Here is What Happened
CRYPTO

Fat-Finger Error Dumps Pump Fun Streamer Coin 99%, Then Surges 10,000%? Here is What Happened

September 3, 2025
Load More

Related News

Shiba Inu Makes History With Folks Finance Integration, Price Sees Fresh Momentum

Shiba Inu Makes History With Folks Finance Integration, Price Sees Fresh Momentum

September 4, 2025
PEPE Faces 15% Downside Risk as Trading Volumes Collapse

PEPE Faces 15% Downside Risk as Trading Volumes Collapse

September 4, 2025
Dogecoin Price Analysis: Lower Highs Form as Volume Expands on Declines

Dogecoin Price Analysis: Lower Highs Form as Volume Expands on Declines

September 4, 2025
XRP $50,000 Price Predictions and the Disappearing Forbes Report Stir Market Frenzy

XRP $50,000 Price Predictions and the Disappearing Forbes Report Stir Market Frenzy

September 4, 2025
Market Summary: What Happened in Crypto Today?

Market Summary: What Happened in Crypto Today?

September 3, 2025
Twitter Telegram Threads

BLOCKNEWS.COM

BlockNews is your premier source for real-time cryptocurrency, blockchain, political and financial market news.

Stay ahead of the herd with BlockNews

RESOURCES

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Editorial Policies
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap

DISCLOSURES AND POLICIES

BlockNews provides independent reporting on crypto, blockchain, and digital finance. Content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Sponsored material is always disclosed. By using this site, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

© 2025 BlockNews

No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • BITCOIN
  • CRYPTO
    • ETHEREUM
    • RIPPLE XRP
    • SOLANA
    • CARDANO
    • BINANCE BNB
    • DOGECOIN
    • TRON
    • LITECOIN
    • CHAINLINK
    • SUI
  • MEMECOINS
  • POLITICS
  • FINANCE
  • NFT
  • DEFI
  • GUIDES

© 2025 BlockNews