BlockNews.com
  • Crypto
  • NFT
  • Metaverse
  • DeFi
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Opinion
  • Guides
No Result
View All Result
SUBSCRIBE
BlockNews.com
  • Crypto
  • NFT
  • Metaverse
  • DeFi
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Opinion
  • Guides
No Result
View All Result
BlockNews.com
No Result
View All Result
Home Crypto

ETH Can Be a Security and a Commodity: Former CFTC Commissioner

BlockNews Team by BlockNews Team
May 25, 2023
in Crypto, Finance, Investing, Politics
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
Ethereum-Coin
1
SHARES
12
VIEWS
Share on TwitterShare on Reddit
  • Former CFTC Commissioner Claims ETH Can Be Both a Commodity and a Security
  • Conflicting Statements from CFTC and SEC Fuel Legal Ambiguity Surrounding Ethereum
  • Regulatory Uncertainty Hampers Crypto Companies as Ethereum’s Classification Debate Continues

Ethereum’s native token, Ether (ETH), can be classified as both a commodity and a security, according to former United States Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) commissioner Dan Berkovitz. In a recent episode of Laura Shin’s Unchained podcast, Berkovitz, who also served as general counsel at the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), highlighted the overlapping legal definitions that allow for such a classification.

You might also like

Crypto Firms Jockey for Hong Kong Licenses Ahead of June 1 Retail Opening

Tether partners with CityPay.io to expand its reach in Georgia.

Wall Street Prepares To Take On Established Crypto Companies

The ongoing debate over Ether’s legal status stems from contradictory statements issued by the CFTC and the SEC. While the CFTC has consistently labeled Ether and several other cryptocurrencies as commodities over the past six months, the SEC has yet to assign a definitive legal category to Ether. SEC Chair Gary Gensler stated in an oversight hearing in April that all cryptocurrencies, except Bitcoin (BTC), should be treated as securities but provided no further clarification.

Understanding the Dual Classification

Asserting that a crypto asset can be both a commodity and a security, Berkovitz stated:

“The law is clear. Something can be both a commodity and a security.”

The former CFTC commissioner clarified that the confusion arises because commodities are not strictly limited to physical goods like wheat or oats. Instead, anything that falls under the scope of a futures contract can be classified as a commodity. He pointed out that the CFTC’s name includes the term “futures.” 

Berkovitz added that securities, as defined by the Securities Act and the Exchange Act, can also be the subject of futures contracts, placing them under the jurisdiction of the CFTC.

Collin Lloyd, a partner at law firm Sullivan & Cromwell, challenged the SEC’s stance on categorizing all cryptocurrencies, except Bitcoin, as securities. He argued that the question should focus on whether a digital asset is being sold as part of a securities transaction rather than whether it inherently qualifies as a security. He stated:

“It’s kind of a weird question to be asking, ‘Is this digital asset a security or not?’ You should be asking, ‘Is this digital asset being sold as part of a securities transaction?’ That depends on the facts and circumstances.”

Sullivan & Cromwell has been actively involved in the FTX bankruptcy case and was hired by Coinbase to navigate its regulatory battle with the SEC.

Regulatory Uncertainty Hampers Crypto Companies

The discord between the CFTC and the SEC has implications for the compliance efforts of cryptocurrency companies and exchanges. With clear guidelines and collaboration between the two regulatory bodies, the certainty surrounding the status of digital assets like Ethereum persists. This regulatory ambiguity drives talent, innovation, and investment overseas, depriving the United States of potential benefits.

On May 23, CFTC Chair Rostin Behnam also faced the burning question on the Bloomberg podcast. He addressed the issue of Ethereum’s classification, particularly regarding other layer-1 blockchain assets like Solana. He noted that the existence of listed futures contracts for Bitcoin and Ethereum is driven by market demand and exchange initiatives rather than the specific categorization as commodities or securities. 

Behnam emphasized that the CFTC examines the characteristics of financial assets to ensure compliance with the law and to determine if they fall within the definition of a commodity.

Ethereum’s Identity Crisis Continues

The ongoing debate surrounding Ethereum’s classification as a security or a commodity adds to the overall uncertainty in the United States crypto asset regulatory landscape. The legal battle between Ripple Labs and the SEC has also raised questions about the differential treatment of Ethereum and XRP. However, once the CFTC and the SEC can establish clear guidelines with guidance from Congress, the regulatory uncertainty in the United States is likely to persist, hindering the growth of the industry and encouraging innovation and investment to move overseas.

Tags: CFTCcryptoCrypto Regulationeth
TweetShareShare

Recommended For You

Crypto Firms Jockey for Hong Kong Licenses Ahead of June 1 Retail Opening

by BlockNews Team
June 3, 2023
0
crypto firms china

China is taking the step forward to become a crypto hub and is soon to release retail trading. Hong Kong’s retail trading regime is days away from going...

Read more

Tether partners with CityPay.io to expand its reach in Georgia.

by BlockNews Team
June 3, 2023
0
citypay.io

Tether joins Binance in taking advantage of crypto-friendly Georgia by partnering with the payment system, CityPay. Tether’s growth could be partially attributed to the decline of its competitor,...

Read more

Wall Street Prepares To Take On Established Crypto Companies

by BlockNews Team
June 3, 2023
0
wall street

Wall Street's traditional financial giants are entering the crypto space to offer dependable platforms for institutional investors and challenge the dominance of established exchanges. By developing their digital...

Read more

What The ‘Anti-Mining Bill’ Means For The Crypto Industry In Texas

by BlockNews Team
June 3, 2023
0
texas anti mining bill

Protesters assemble to oppose Senate Bill 1751, which seeks to eliminate tax incentives for crypto mining businesses, causing controversy in Texas, a major participant in cryptocurrency regulation. Mining...

Read more

Bank of Japan Releases CBDC Report and Launched Its Pilot Program As Other Countries Gain Steam

by BlockNews Team
June 3, 2023
0
bank of japan

With the introduction of its CBDC pilot program, the Bank of Japan set the bar high as interest in central bank digital currencies develops globally. The Bank of...

Read more
Next Post
Binance-Logo-on-Phone

Cryptocurrency Exchange Binance Cleared in $8 Million Tinder Scam Lawsuit

Related News

Around the Block

Around The Block – MAR 3rd Week in News

March 3, 2023
paypal building sign

PayPal Co-Invests $20M in On-Chain Risk Optimizing Fintech Startup Chaos Labs

February 25, 2023
Current NFT Market Conditions – Analysis

Current NFT Market Conditions – Analysis

June 22, 2022

Browse by Category

  • Breaking News
  • Business
  • Crypto
  • DeFi
  • Finance
  • Gaming
  • Guides
  • Investing
  • Media
  • Metaverse
  • NFT
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Social
  • Technology
  • Uncategorized
BlockNews.com

BlockNews.com brings you the most important Crypto and NFT news in the space.

CATEGORIES

  • Breaking News
  • Business
  • Crypto
  • DeFi
  • Finance
  • Gaming
  • Guides
  • Investing
  • Media
  • Metaverse
  • NFT
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Social
  • Technology
  • Uncategorized

RECENT POSTS

  • Crypto Firms Jockey for Hong Kong Licenses Ahead of June 1 Retail Opening June 3, 2023
  • Tether partners with CityPay.io to expand its reach in Georgia. June 3, 2023
  • Wall Street Prepares To Take On Established Crypto Companies June 3, 2023

© 2022 BlockNews.com - Crypto and NFT news website by JRNY Club.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Crypto
  • NFT
  • Metaverse
  • DeFi
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Opinion
  • Guides

© 2022 BlockNews.com - Crypto and NFT news website by JRNY Club.

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?