BlockNews
FOLLOW ON X
  • BITCOIN
  • CRYPTO
    • ETHEREUM
    • RIPPLE XRP
    • SOLANA
    • CARDANO
    • BINANCE BNB
    • DOGECOIN
    • TRON
    • SUI
    • CHAINLINK
    • LITECOIN
  • FINANCE
  • POLITICS
  • MEMECOINS
  • NFT
  • OPINION
No Result
View All Result
BlockNews
  • BITCOIN
  • CRYPTO
    • ETHEREUM
    • RIPPLE XRP
    • SOLANA
    • CARDANO
    • BINANCE BNB
    • DOGECOIN
    • TRON
    • SUI
    • CHAINLINK
    • LITECOIN
  • FINANCE
  • POLITICS
  • MEMECOINS
  • NFT
  • OPINION
No Result
View All Result
BlockNews
Home BUSINESS

Users Will Decide if They Can Still Trust Ledger with Their Seed Phrases

BlockNews Team by BlockNews Team
May 24, 2023
in BUSINESS, MEDIA, SOCIAL, TECHNOLOGY
Reading Time: 4 mins read
1
SHARES
21
VIEWS
Share on XShare in TelegramShare on Reddit
  • Ledger has a new “recover” mode that give a third party your seed phrase.
  • Ledger’s decision to introduce a third party to your wallet seed phrase created an exploit that could appeal to both governments and hackers.
  • This has made Ledgers customers skeptical of their wallet’s security. They now see a possible way of being exploited.

Self-custody is important in crypto, and security is essential to self-custody. Ledger, a notable hardware wallet manufacturer, has built its reputation on the secure storage of users’ private keys. Hardware wallets create a safe offline environment for storing and using keys to execute transactions.

The user’s private keys are generated and stored within the device and are supposed never to leave it. This “cold storage” provides an unrivaled level of security compared with “hot wallets” or online wallets. The problem is that lots of people lose their keys.

Ledger rolled out a seed phrase backup product this week called Ledger Recover. If you give the company your ID and personal information, you can pay for a service that takes your seed phrase within your device, encrypts it into three “shards,” and then shares them with various custodians.

Introducing a third party inherently centralizes control, creating a single point of failure that hackers could exploit or be subject to regulatory actions.

I don’t begrudge Ledger’s effort to grow as a business to reach non-OG and non-cypherpunk-ethos users. Millions of normies, like our skeptical baby boomer in-laws, will only ever be onboarded to crypto through this custodial backup approach. Its mistake may have been using the same product to appeal to crypto self-custody OGs and the broader future customer normies.

Ledger’s rollout of its backup product met with some strong reactions among its community of customers. Many were surprised that Ledger could always touch your secret key with its hardware updates. Many of us view our hardware devices as sacrosanct. I needed to be more knowledgeable about this device I trust to protect my crypto assets.

Haseeb Qureshi said that while he reacted negatively at first, he realized that this was always true about Ledger. We’ve always trusted it not to insert malware in its firmware updates to steal our seed phrases. He’s not wrong, but that’s not a comforting thought.

Ultimately, everything can happen on your hardware device if you sign a transaction. You retain the power. I don’t know about you, but I’m not a coder — I can’t tell a malicious update from a legitimate one, so I’m trusting Ledger on that too. And I don’t have the option not to approve the latest firmware update that includes Ledger Recover capability, as Ledger warns that failure to update your firmware is a security risk.

I do trust Ledger — it’s a great company. It has been the linchpin in the technology stack for crypto self-custody, at least in my crypto journey.

But the goal of a crypto self-custody tool should be to minimize trust requirements. And that could be improved at Ledger through open-sourcing more of its software and hardware. Ledger’s chief technology officer was asked about this on May 17’s Bankless podcast and responded that Ledger has signed nondisclosure agreements that preclude it from doing so and argued that people are unlikely to crowdsource security audits anyway.

Security researchers like Andrew Miller, who uncovered vulnerabilities in the Secret Network, would take up that task.

While Ledger’s communications regarding the rollout have been a disaster, its crisis communications have been enlightening. I had an insufficient understanding of how hardware wallets work. But “Sorry, we can’t open-source anything because of NDAs” is an inadequate answer to those in the community concerned that a malicious actor could use Ledger Recover to trick users with a fake update and steal their seed phrase.

Ledger could also allow me to continue to update my firmware without adding the Ledger Recover code to my device. But in the absence of open-sourcing its firmware, it will only do a little, as we won’t have any way to verify its claims.

This could be a branding win if Ledger pivoted to roll out a “cypherpunk”-branded dimension to its hardware and software that appeases the OG crypto community such that they might be willing to opt into it and lets existing hardware owners opt into it for their previously purchased hardware such that new updates are cypherpunk-branded and -approved, as open source as possible, with crowdsourced security audits — the whole package. All would be forgiven.

For now, it doesn’t seem Ledger plans to do that. So, the options are to use open-source hardware wallets, but those need Ledger’s wide-ranging interoperability with emerging blockchains. Or you could build your own or use the new refurbished Gameboy open-source hardware wallet.

For now, and for many coins, the safest option is to trust Ledger while staying open to competing developers of open-source hardware wallets.

Disclaimer: BlockNews provides independent reporting on crypto, blockchain, and digital finance. All content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Readers should do their own research before making investment decisions. Some articles may use AI tools to assist in drafting, but every piece is reviewed and edited by our editorial team of experienced crypto writers and analysts before publication.
Tags: Cold WalletHardware WalletLedgerTechnology
TweetShareShare
BlockNews Team

BlockNews Team

DON'T MISS THESE! HOT OFF THE PRESS

Bitcoin vs Stocks: Why AI May Push BTC Ahead in the Next Decades
BITCOIN

Bitcoin vs Stocks: Why AI May Push BTC Ahead in the Next Decades

August 31, 2025
Raoul Pal Says XRP Is About to Leave the “Waiting Room” and Enter a New Growth Phase
BUSINESS

Raoul Pal Says XRP Is About to Leave the “Waiting Room” and Enter a New Growth Phase

September 1, 2025
Dogecoin Rebounds as Elon Musk’s Lawyer Pushes Bold $200M Treasury Plan
BUSINESS

Dogecoin Rebounds as Elon Musk’s Lawyer Pushes Bold $200M Treasury Plan

August 30, 2025
Hut 8 Expands With 1.5 GW of New Bitcoin Mining Sites Across the US
BITCOIN

Hut 8 Expands With 1.5 GW of New Bitcoin Mining Sites Across the US

August 26, 2025
Aave and World Liberty Financial Proposal Sparks Debate in DeFi
BUSINESS

Aave and World Liberty Financial Proposal Sparks Debate in DeFi

August 25, 2025
SBI and Chainlink Team Up to Push Global Blockchain Adoption
BUSINESS

SBI and Chainlink Team Up to Push Global Blockchain Adoption

August 25, 2025
Load More

Related News

Hyperliquid Smashes Records with $106M Revenue in August

Hyperliquid Smashes Records with $106M Revenue in August

September 2, 2025
HBAR Bulls Show Signs of Life but Key Test Still Ahead

HBAR Bulls Show Signs of Life but Key Test Still Ahead

September 2, 2025
Stellar Nears Make-or-Break Support as Bulls Eye Next Move

Stellar Nears Make-or-Break Support as Bulls Eye Next Move

September 2, 2025
Avalanche Balances on Key Levels as ETF Hopes Fuel Speculation

Avalanche Balances on Key Levels as ETF Hopes Fuel Speculation

September 2, 2025
SUI Balances on $3.20 Support as Traders Watch the Wedge

SUI Balances on $3.20 Support as Traders Watch the Wedge

September 2, 2025
Twitter Telegram Threads

BLOCKNEWS.COM

BlockNews is your premier source for real-time cryptocurrency, blockchain, political and financial market news.

Stay ahead of the herd with BlockNews

RESOURCES

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Editorial Policies
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap

DISCLOSURES AND POLICIES

BlockNews provides independent reporting on crypto, blockchain, and digital finance. Content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Sponsored material is always disclosed. By using this site, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

© 2025 BlockNews

No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • BITCOIN
  • CRYPTO
    • ETHEREUM
    • RIPPLE XRP
    • SOLANA
    • CARDANO
    • BINANCE BNB
    • DOGECOIN
    • TRON
    • LITECOIN
    • CHAINLINK
    • SUI
  • MEMECOINS
  • POLITICS
  • FINANCE
  • NFT
  • DEFI
  • GUIDES

© 2025 BlockNews